Other Cases & Materials
Case Collection
Pluralism in Practice (Orbis, 2023). A collection of twelve cases, including three new case studies and updated versions of the Pluralism Project's most-requested case studies. This volume also features discussion questions for each case and an afterword by Diana Eck with guidance on teaching and learning with case studies.
Additional Cases & Case Collections
Rumors in Damascus (A) and (B)
Emir Abd el-Kader, a 19th century Algerian statesman, scholar, and warrior, must respond when he hears rumors that Christians in the city of Damascus will soon be under attack.
Chaplaincy Innovation Lab: Case Studies in Effective Chaplaincy
Evergreen College: Native Case Studies
HBS Cases: Religion
Mercy Medical Centre: Orchestrating Diversity and Inclusion in a Dutch Hospital, Michelle van Koert, Maartje Schouten, Tao Yue, Nov 2024.
The Dutch hospital Mercy Medical Centre has committed to creating a more diverse and inclusive environment by signing a Declaration of Intent on diversity and inclusion (D&I), recognizing its ethical and business importance. Despite this commitment, however, Mercy faces uncertainty in addressing various D&I-related challenges.
Art Gallery Forbidden Exhibit Community Dialogue Role-Play, Twila Albrecht, May 2023.
A select committee meeting to determine how to proceed with a controversial art exhibit installed a few weeks earlier at a small gallery at a Minnesota college. Based on true events, this role play highlights the difficulty in navigating the intersection of freedom of expression and religious representation amidst political discord.
Managing Religion in the Workplace: Abercrombie & Fitch and Masterpiece Cakeshop, Derek C.M. van Bever, Mar 20, 2018
This case examines two incidents of alleged religious discrimination heard in the US Supreme Court, allowing students to explore whether business owners and leaders can and should express their values in the context of commerce.
Divided We Stand: Gay Marriage Rulings and Official Disobedience, Laura Winig, Christopher Robichaud, Aug 24, 2016
This case explores recent examples of government officials disobeying legal rulings on gay marriage and invites students to explore whether the officials were justified or not.
Faith and Work: Hobby Lobby and AutoZone, Timothy Ewest, David M Miller, Kacee Garner, Holly Huser, Feb 4, 2015
This case considers two organizational sides of integrating faith into the workplace: the employee and employer perspectives.
Religion/Spirituality in the Workplace: Vignettes, Andrew C Wicks, Jenny Mead, Nicholas Stewart, Jan 1, 2012
These 14 vignettes have been developed to facilitate a discussion on the place of spirituality or religion in the workplace.
Other Case Resources
News articles, brief scenarios, films, and other narratives can serve to augment—or even take the place of–case studies when teaching with the case method in religion and interfaith studies. Ideally, these materials would have some of the essential elements of a case study, including context, complexity, ambiguity, and relevance. (From Richard Fossey and Gary M. Crow, "The Elements of a Good Case." Journal of Cases in Educational Leadership 14, no. 3 (September 2011)) Below are some examples of book chapters, news articles, and other resources that might function as case studies and could be taught using the case method of discussion.
A selection of more recent articles that can be discussed as cases may be found in Interfaith America's Pluralism Texts Bibliography.
“Cherokee fight over graduations at churches could spread across Metro Atlanta”
Is holding high school graduations in a local megachurch a cost-saving measure or a violation of religious rights?
“Climbers Ignore Native Americans’ Request at Devils Tower”
Hikers ignore the National Park Service’s voluntary ban of hiking Devils Tower, claiming they also have spiritual and recreational rights to the sacred land known as “Bear Lodge” in Lakota.
“Alabama To Put Ten Commandment Displays on November Ballot”
Should voters decide if Ten Commandment monuments can be displayed on State property?
Video: “Who owns yoga?”
The video's section on America, which includes the Hindu American Foundation’s "Take Back Yoga" campaign, Christian yoga, and the Encinitas yoga dispute, begins at 11:33.
“’A second-best decision’” (Duke call to prayer controversy)
News of a proposed weekly call to prayer, to be sounded from the tower of iconic Duke Chapel, generates national controversy. How will Duke University leadership respond, and what does this controversy say about the role of the chapel—and the challenges of pluralism—on college campuses today?
“Test of Faith”
A Wellesley, MA educator brings his students to local religious centers to learn about diverse faiths, but faces criticism from two sources: a Harvard Divinity School lecturer dedicated to religious literacy and an anti-Muslim advocate
"11th Circuit Considers Religious Freedom of Buddhist Meditation Center"
When the Thai Meditation Association of Alabama applied to open a religious facility, they explained to city officials that meditation wasn’t tied to one religion and that the center would be open to all. With the zoning application denied, the Thai Buddhist community must now prove that the center is a religious facility.
“Hindu Swastika Sparks Controversy at Irvine Museum”
When a Hindu swastika is displayed at a children’s museum in Irvine, CA, controversy ensues. Should it be removed?
“Student allowed to bring religious knife to school”
When a Sikh student begins wearing a kirpan to elementary school in Auburn, WA, some worry that the small dagger poses a threat to student safety. If you can’t take it on a plane, should you be able to take it to school?
“Ordination at CRC stirs controversy”
When a synagogue in St. Louis, MO hosts the ordination of two Catholic women as priests, in a ceremony not recognized by Roman Catholic law, it strains Catholic-Jewish relations. Is it a stand against patriarchal relations or an act of disrespect?
“Don’t Leave Atheists Out”
Is there a place for Atheists in interfaith dialogue? What are the barriers? What are the limits?
Books
Lucinda Mosher, Elinor J. Pierce, and Or N. Rose, With the Best of Intentions: Interreligious Missteps and Mistakes. Maryknoll, New York: Orbis Books, 2023. This book explores new ground, inviting contributors to consider mistakes: as such, the individual chapters can function as "failure cases."
Mikva, Rachel S. Interreligious Studies: An Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023. This book takes a case study approach, with "case summaries" informed by the Pluralism Project's work.
Lehmann, Karsten, ed. Talking Dialogue: Eleven Episodes in the History of the Modern Interreligious Dialogue Movement. Berlin: DeGruyter Brill, 2021. A collection of dialogue case studies .
Sana, Loue, ed. Case Studies in Society, Religion, and Bioethics. Switzerland: Springer, 2020. A book of case studies with an interdisciplinary approach.
Paul D. Numrich, The Faith Next Door: American Christians and Their New Religious Neighbors. New York: Oxford University Press, 2009. This book considers interactions between Christians and their multireligious neighbors in a nation and time of growing diversity.
Jennifer Peace, Or Rose, and Gregory Mobley, eds. My Neighbor’s Faith: Stories of Interreligious Encounter, Growth and Transformation. New York: Orbis Books, 2012. This collection of stories from leaders, scholars and activists explores interreligious encounters around the world and what they mean for today’s society.
Case Resources from Interfaith America
Pluralism and Religious Difference Case Studies